Vanderbilt dropped its first SEC contest of the season to the No. 2 Georgia Bulldogs on Saturday. (Hustler Multimedia/Mattigan Kelly). (Mattigan Kelly)
Vanderbilt dropped its first SEC contest of the season to the No. 2 Georgia Bulldogs on Saturday. (Hustler Multimedia/Mattigan Kelly).

Mattigan Kelly

Commodore Brunch Week Four: Dog food

In the first SEC game of his tenure, Clark Lea’s team was absolutely dominated by the No. 2 Georgia Bulldogs, demonstrating his roster is simply not yet fit for elite competition.

September 26, 2021

Before sitting down to write Commodore Brunch columns, I always re-watch Saturday’s game first. Sorry, but I refuse to do that today.

Besides the fact that it would offer me such little new information, Vanderbilt’s 62-0 loss to No. 2 Georgia yesterday was unwatchable in its first iteration. I can’t imagine sitting through it once again. 

From start to finish, this was an absolute throttling. Many anticipated a rough afternoon for the Commodores—including Las Vegas, which put the line at 36 points—but the fashion in which it happened was simply startling. The game’s ending result was never in doubt, but I can’t say I expected eight Georgia touchdowns.

“From the start we were interested in Vanderbilt,” head coach Clark Lea said after the loss. “Georgia’s a good team and they deserve to be where they are in the rankings. They are playing at a high level but I am interested in when we can find our highest level performance.” 

Lea’s team certainly didn’t find its highest level of performance on Saturday. The Bulldogs scored 35 points in the first quarter alone in their victory. 21 of those points were scored in the first seven minutes of the game, putting this one away before many Vanderbilt students even arrived. Two separate Bulldogs—Ladd McConkey and Brock Bowers—notched rushing and receiving touchdowns in the quarter, the first time a Georgia player has done that since Todd Gurley in 2013. 

Vanderbilt totaled 77 yards of offense—just 15 more than Georgia’s point total. Three first downs, nine punts and two turnovers later, Vanderbilt got what it deserved: the Commodores were dog food on Saturday and the Bulldogs munched their way to a decisive victory in front of, well, a mostly red crowd.

Full dose of five-star talent

Last week, South Carolina head coach Shane Beamer adequately described this year’s Georgia football team by saying that they have, “like 100 five-star football players on their defense.”

I’ll fact check the first-year head coach: they do not have 100. But they have a lot.

Per 247Sports rankings, Georgia starts a total of eight five-star players and nine four-star players. That means 17 of 22 starters are four or five-star players. Vanderbilt starts zero five-star players and one four-star player—Cam Johnson. Some quick math shows that Georgia starts 16 more four or five-star players.

“The [defensive] numbers speak for themselves,” Lea said of Georgia’s defense in particular. “They have done a great job building a roster and coaching that roster to a high level. They earned it today. They earned it in all three phases.”

To expect the Commodores to be remotely competitive in this game would have been foolish. And while the simple narrative that Vanderbilt football lacks talent may be overused, it’s just plain true. The current talent disparity between Vanderbilt and other SEC teams may be at an all-time high. For this program to elevate its status in the conference, recruiting efforts and development will have to change.

The Commodores were dominated in the trenches for the second consecutive week, surrendering yards of push on the defensive side and failing to buy time for Ken Seals and Mike Wright on the offensive side. Consistent pressure down the middle and off the edges accounted for much of Vanderbilt’s disastrous 1.7 yards per play average. And once again, a lack of pressure on the opposing quarterback left Vanderbilt cornerbacks on islands all afternoon.

But when considering the talent differential, none of these trends should be surprising. Vanderbilt’s average starting defensive lineman weighs 284 pounds. Georgia’s average starting offensive lineman weighs about 314 pounds. On the other side, Bulldog starting pass rushers average out at 310 pounds—the exact same number as Vanderbilt’s five starting offensive linemen.

There is a simple explanation for Vanderbilt’s lack of production on the defensive line this season and it revolves around these very issues. One sack in four games is certainly not going to get it done in the SEC and that was evident on Saturday.

Self-Sabotage

The focus of this week in practice? According to the head man, controlling Vanderbilt.

“From the start we were interested in Vanderbilt,” Lea said. “We came out flat, we turned the ball over, we made mistakes in the special teams area. It doesn’t matter who you play against, you are setting yourself up for disappointment.”

Without directly saying it, Lea is clearly pointing to the fact that a victory this week wasn’t in the cards. The first-year head coach was most concerned with how his team executed the processes and style that he is attempting to implement—it’s the right strategy for a coach leading a team with little chance at more than a single conference win.

But this week, Vanderbilt failed to live up to his expectations. For the third straight week, his team was not prepared from the get-go. In each of the Commodores’ last three games, they have surrendered a touchdown within the first four minutes of the game. This week, they surrendered five touchdowns by the first quarter’s end.

That is nothing but unacceptable and for a team that is already playing behind talent-wise, it basically digs Vanderbilt a grave each week. This group is far from learning how to win tough games but winning them by coming back from being down? Forget about it.

Much of what plagued the Commodores early was turnovers. The Ken Seals experience continues to be a roller coaster ride, as the sophomore made more questionable decisions on Saturday. A first-down interception midway through the first quarter allowed Georgia to extend their lead to 28 by going just 21 yards. 

He often looked anxious in the shotgun, moving his feet quickly and hardly looking past his first read. I guess you can’t blame him—he had 6’6”, 340-pound Jordan Davis running straight at him quite a bit—but he has still failed to demonstrate the consistency fans were looking for after a promising freshman season.

It’s difficult to critique Vanderbilt’s gameplan very much considering it only ran 46 plays, but it’s clear the running situation will be a problem in Re’Mahn Davis’ absence as the coaching staff had no creative solutions on Saturday. Rocko Griffin, Patrick Smith and James Ziglor combined to run 16 times for 18 yards. That ain’t going to do it down the stretch of this SEC slate.

Ziglor also fumbled a kickoff return in the first quarter and that begs the question: why wasn’t Lea’s gameplan to simply fair catch every single kick all game?

Lea has to help Vanderbilt take care of Vanderbilt. And it didn’t appear that he did against Georgia.

“The long hard way”

It’s impossible to look at Vanderbilt’s performance yesterday in a vacuum and be confident and excited about Clark Lea and the direction of this football program. On paper, each and every thing about it was negative. But again, what has to be remembered is the broader status of this football program.

“This is a measure of where we are right now, but certainly not an indicator of where we are headed,” Lea said. “For me, this isn’t about them, it’s about us, it’s about how we performed, it’s about the things that we can do. That starts with me.”

Vanderbilt football is a ways away from competing against top-five SEC competition. But it’s not like that hasn’t been the case since the James Franklin era. Over their last 13 SEC games, Vanderbilt is 1-12 with a loss margin of 26 points. Yeah, yesterday it was a little more than that, but let’s not act like embarrassing SEC losses are a new phenomenon at Vanderbilt.

Lea is playing the long game and to leave this season with any optimism, Vanderbilt fans will have to play along. Effort, time and money are slowly being thrown into this program regardless of 2021 boxscores. The football staff is larger than it has ever been, the Vandy United campaign is underway and Lea’s first recruiting class is shaping up quite nicely. 

There will be plenty of SEC losses to come this season—likely next season as well. They may not be as embarrassing as this one, but they are inevitable with the current state of Vanderbilt’s roster. While hard to see in the rage of a pathetic loss, broader positives do exist regardless of whether we saw them on the field this weekend.

“This is just a point in the progression line. It doesn’t shake us because we understand it doesn’t define us. This is a delicate ecosystem, we are young, we are in the infancy of our program,” Lea said calmly. “This is the long hard way.”

View Comments (2)
2

Comments (2)

The Vanderbilt Hustler welcomes and encourages readers to engage with content and express opinions through the comments section on our website and social media platforms. However, The Hustler reserves the right to remove comments that violate the outlined policy. Comments which contain vulgarity, hate speech, personal attacks or appear to be spam or commercial promotion will be blocked or removed by The Hustler. The comments section, both on the website and social media, is moderated by the Editor in Chief.
All The Vanderbilt Hustler Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
D
Daniel
22 days ago

I was there for the 65-0 beat down by UT in 1994. This was far worse. GA could have scored 100.

C
Cory93
20 days ago
Reply to  Daniel

DiNardo’s parting gift. I was there, too – well, the first half of it.
I didn’t watch this week’s game, but I’m not sure I’ve ever seen an uglier Vandy box score.
I’m still hopeful for Coach Lea, but his unconventional (and emotionless) style have a way to go to prove themselves.