The official student newspaper of Vanderbilt University

The Vanderbilt Hustler

The official student newspaper of Vanderbilt University.
Since 1888
The official student newspaper of Vanderbilt University

The Vanderbilt Hustler

The official student newspaper of Vanderbilt University.
The official student newspaper of Vanderbilt University

The Vanderbilt Hustler

The official student newspaper of Vanderbilt University.

THORNTON: Should confederate statues be demolished with a bulldozer or a wrecking ball?

Confederate Memorial Hall on Commons

In 1949, on the heels of World War II, Germany banned the usage of the swastika. Since 1945, the German government has worked to rid the country of Nazi-era memorials. Nazi headquarters have been transformed into educational spaces. Jails that housed high-ranking Nazi officers have been torn down. Even the bunker that Adolf Hitler committed suicide in has been plastered over and buried under a parking lot. It is now marked with only a small plaque; additionally, most Nazi burial sites remain unmarked.


Germany has learned to grapple with its past without glorifying it. So why can’t America do the same thing? Why are states still allowed to fly the Confederate Flag? Why haven’t we torn down Confederate monuments of men who were monsters. Germany poured concrete over their most famous oppressors nearly seven decades ago, while, in America, we still have shrines of our own.


Keeping these shrines of monsters glorifies oppressors and spits on the graves of those they called slave. The lack of integrity in the way some schools decide to teach about slavery further spits on those graves. The United States has no mandatory standard on how to talk about slavery in schools, and without a set mandate, we allow schools to teach slavery in sickening ways or deeply misrepresent it. Not only does this fail to preserve the authenticity of the disgusting underbelly of American history, but it also upholds the verdict that keeping up Confederate statues embody. As reported by The Atlantic, students across the country, ranging from third grade to high school are being assigned to reenact slave ships in class, list reasons why Africans made ‘good slaves’, create slave auction advertisement posters and runaway slave wanted signs, and given math word problems about slavery, beatings, and picking fruit and cotton, absent of any historical context. It’s appalling to imagine 8-year-olds doing addition and subtraction with the number of beatings a slave received or the amount of cotton he picked, yet it continues to happen. Just as the continued standing of confederate statues shows, these horrendous mistakes in American history education treat slavery as just another way of life, rather than truly encapsulating the atrocity and disregards the toll it takes on an entire population of American citizens. Additionally, it helps lay the groundwork for those who argue that confederate monuments are history rather than modern support of the institution.


Germany poured concrete over their most famous oppressors nearly seven decades ago, while, in America, we still have shrines of our own.


That’s not even the worst of it. Some textbooks continue to refer to slavery as the “peculiar institution,” as opposed to a mass atrocity; some minimize the horror of slavery by referring to slaves as “workers”. Not only is it time for the United States government to enact a law that requires schools to teach the country’s history properly, but the country as whole should start treating slavery for what it was: a labor-based genocide. Since 1800, the African-American population has sextupled. Why? Because the institutionalized massacre of Black people was halted in 1865.


The day that America finally refers to the “peculiar institution” as a genocide will be the day that confederate monuments are nowhere to be seen except in Civil War museums, disremembering them as heroes. It wasn’t until this year that the city of Memphis (a majority-Black community) took down its statue of Nathan Bedford Forrest: a Confederate general, slave trader and the first leader of the Ku Klux Klan. The city had to utilize a legal loophole to avoid violating the state’s laws against the removal of these monuments.


The Sons of Confederacy and Forrest’s relatives have attempted to sue the city for millions of dollars, claiming that it violated the Tennessee Heritage Protection Act. They received assistance from the Republican-dominated state house, which decided to punish Memphis by withholding $250,000 in funding for the city’s bicentennial celebration next year. It’s understandable that Forrest’s descendants are upset with the demolition of his statue, considering that he’s family. However, just as they have to deal with the fact that their forefather was a slave-owner and Klan leader, millions of African Americans today have to grapple with the fact that their recent ancestors were slaves.


Similar to the case of the Memphis statue, Vanderbilt received Confederate Memorial Hall from the Daughters of the Confederacy in 1935. Recently, Vanderbilt had to pay the Daughters over one million dollars to remove the word “Confederate” from the Hall. Standing in the heart of Ingram Commons and housing dozens of first-years, the University took action just two years ago.


throughout the state, I’m still likely to run into statues of soldiers who defended the institution of slavery.


More than 700 Confederate statues and monuments still stand in the U.S. The city of Memphis only wanted to replace its statue with a Civil War museum or memorial. By keeping these shrines around, we forget the amount of pain and death these Confederate leaders were responsible for and reconstruct them them as our nation’s defenders. Robert E. Lee’s shrine should be replaced with one of Harriet Tubman; postage stamps with the faces of white supremacists should be discontinued. Each monument should be demolished and replaced with Civil War memorials, abolitionist statues or tributes to slaves who fought for freedom.


Luckily, since my move to Nashville, I never had to see glorifications of slavery on campus. However, throughout the state, I’m still likely to run into statues of soldiers who defended the institution of slavery. Take Sam Davis, otherwise known as the “Boy Hero of the Confederacy.” The American Nazis have used his symbol in Pulaski, Tennessee–the birthplace of the KKK. His statue stands in Centennial Park, just a few blocks from main campus. Additionally, a bust of Nathan Bedford Forrest is enshrined in the state Capitol. When unveiled in 1978, it was criticized as an “insult to Blacks.” Forty years later, through multiple protests, this statue and other shrines of the Confederacy still stand as personal insults. They memorialize people whom my ancestors were forced to call master.


Miquéla Thornton is a first-year in the College of Arts and Science. She can be reached at [email protected].

View comments (5)
About the Contributor
Miquéla Thornton
Miquéla Thornton, Former Opinion Editor
Miquéla Thornton ('22) is from Chicago-ish, Illinois, and double-majored in creative writing and communication of science and technology, aspiring to be a science writer. She was heavily involved on campus at Vanderbilt New Dawn and The McGill Project. When she isn't writing for The Hustler, she enjoys writing fiction and poetry. Aside from writing, she spends her time painting, roller skating and visiting art galleries around Nashville. She can be reached at [email protected].    

Comments (5)

The Vanderbilt Hustler welcomes and encourages readers to engage with content and express opinions through the comment sections on our website and social media platforms. The Hustler reserves the right to remove comments that contain vulgarity, hate speech, personal attacks or that appear to be spam, commercial promotion or impersonation. The comment sections are moderated by our Editor-in-Chief, Rachael Perrotta, and our Social Media Director, Chloe Postlewaite. You can reach them at [email protected] and [email protected].
All The Vanderbilt Hustler picks Reader picks Sort: Newest
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Raymond Kistler
5 years ago

I agree with the author of this article- When I was in Germany last summer we learned that all things Nazi have been removed, even though it, like the Confederacy did exist. It has been a big part of why Germany has healed relatively well compared to the South which still seems to want to hold onto the most evil part of its’ past. Even the bunker where HItler was killed and found has no marker, it is literally just a paved over parking lot. That is the most appropriate actions. We have enough written history to remind ourselves these awful people existed without glorifying statues and monuments. However with a wanna-be-Adolf as our (appointed) president, I do not see the conservative snowflakes allowing this to take place for another 2-6 years.

5 years ago

While nobody can deny the horrors of the Civil War and the purpose behind it, those monuments that are still in the United States represent a piece of American history that should never be forgotten. Those monuments are important to teach future generations about the actual history of our country. What you and many other supporters of this idea are suggesting is revisionist history to shield Americans from pain and discomfort. Pain and discomfort are unavoidable and must be embraced to truly understand history and how it may shape the future.

5 years ago

If you really want to know if confederate statues should be taken down with a bulldozer or a wrecking ball, I’ve got you covered. Heres The Slant’s take on the matter:

Woke Alum
5 years ago

What a snowflake.

Confederate statues should remain. They represent a vital part of our history and heritage.

5 years ago

I vehemently oppose the ideas of tearing down or alter the statues or building names. That’s what communist Red Guard did to the historical statues/architectural structures during the Chinese Cultural Revolution. That’s anti cultural and anti civilization. The confederation was not Nazis. The Nazis were sentenced to death or prison. Nothing like that happened to the confederate personnel. Confederation is just the side who happened to lose a civil war.